Distilled
A Ugandan bakery lent about USD 2.2 million, unsecured, to related companies in Kenya and Tanzania at 4.6 to 10 per cent. The authority rebuilt the rates from a dollar risk-free rate, the taxpayer's own 4 per cent lending premium and a country risk premium, reaching 10.4 to 13.5 per cent. The Tribunal doubted the country risk add-on but upheld the adjustment: the taxpayer's deposit rates and bank offer were not comparables, and it offered no reliable alternative.
The facts
Mini Bakeries Uganda Limited makes Supa Loaf bread and belongs to a group operating across East Africa. Between 2018 and 2022 it lent in dollars to related companies in Kenya and Tanzania, about USD 2.2 million in total: unsecured, over several years, at 4.6 per cent (Tanzania, 2018), 7 per cent (three Kenyan loans, 2018–2019) and 10 per cent (Kenya 2020, Tanzania 2021–2022). Its transfer pricing documentation covered intercompany loans in three sentences, saying rates would follow Ugandan commercial bank lending rates at the time of lending. The authority described the policy as LIBOR plus 4 per cent.
The authority rebuilt each rate from three parts: a dollar risk-free rate, the 4 per cent lending premium taken from the taxpayer's own documentation, and a separate country risk premium for Kenya and Tanzania. Its rates ran from 10.42 to 13.52 per cent, averaging 12.61 per cent. In defence the taxpayer offered Bank of Uganda deposit rates (averaging 3.46 per cent), central bank lending rates, and a 2022 KCB Bank offer to one of the borrowers.
The decision
The Tribunal rejected each of the taxpayer's benchmarks. The KCB offer was for secured overdraft facilities of Kshs 190 million or USD 8 million, made four years after a USD 500,000 loan, with no adjustment for any of those differences. Deposits carry a different risk from unsecured lending, and a quote is not a transaction. Drawing on paragraphs 10.51 and 10.53 of the Guidelines and on Chevron, it held that the lender's realistically available options, such as deposits or government securities, had to be analysed at the time. They were not.
On the authority's method, the Tribunal sided with the taxpayer in principle. Country risk is ordinarily priced into a lending premium already, and adding a premium for it on top would be inappropriate; the Tribunal expressly declined to endorse risk-free rate plus lending premium plus country premium as a general method. But the burden under section 19 of the Tax Appeals Tribunal Act lay on the taxpayer, which had produced no reliable alternative range, credit analysis or method. The adjustment stood.
ajiho commentary
Right on the method, wrong on the burden
The Tribunal accepted the taxpayer's main criticism and still found against it. That is what a taxpayer burden means in practice: showing the authority's number is flawed does not show the assessment is excessive. Only a better number does that. The contrast with Portugal six days later is exact. In CAAD 979/2025-T the burden sat on the authority, and a flawed method cost it the case.
Your own premium becomes the authority's input
The authority did not invent its lending premium. It took the taxpayer's 4 per cent and asked what it covered, and the file could not say. A premium stated without its components invites exactly this: the authority treats it as credit risk alone and adds the rest. If the 4 per cent was meant to include country risk, the file needed to say so and show it.
A lender's floor is not the borrower's price
A deposit rate measures what the lender gives up, not what an independent lender would charge an unsecured borrower in another country. The two bound a negotiation; they do not settle it. What was missing on both sides was a credit view of the borrowers, and the Tribunal said so: no borrower-specific credit analysis supported the rates. The policy also pointed to Ugandan lending rates for loans made in dollars.
Uganda keeps finding for the authority
After Rwenzori on the interest cap and ATC Uganda on withholding tax on capitalised interest, the authority has now won on loan pricing too. The pattern holds: Ugandan tribunals read the Guidelines closely, insist on contemporaneous documentation and leave the burden where the statute puts it.
The Tribunal did not determine an arm's length rate; it upheld an assessment the taxpayer could not show was excessive. ajiho will continue to monitor East African decisions on intra-group financing.
Case reference
Mini Bakeries Uganda Limited v Uganda Revenue Authority, Tax Appeals Tribunal of Uganda at Kampala, TAT Application No. 330 of 2025, ruling of 21 August 2026. Before: Hon. Crystal Kabajwara (Chairperson), Hon. Stella Nyapendi Chombo, Hon. Rebecca Proscovia Nambi. Period: July 2015 to June 2023. Primary source: official ruling (a scanned document; text taken by OCR and figures checked against the page images).
The ruling gives loan tenors as 3 to 5 years in one place and 3 to 7 years in another. The loan schedule records the 2020 Kenyan rate as "10% per quarter"; the taxpayer's benchmark table shows 10 per cent, treated here as annual, and that table also appears to swap the 2018 Kenya and Tanzania rates. The Transfer Pricing Regulations are referred to as 2011 in one place and 2016 in another.