Signal — FT Cases

A…, Lda v Autoridade Tributária e Aduaneira

An authority that calls a comparable set unreliable cannot then price off its median. For 2019, no rule required the median at all.

Distilled

A Portuguese company paid 6.098 per cent on a €25 million loan from its parent, supported by a comparable search that put the rate between the third quartile and the maximum. The authority trimmed the sample, faulted it on rating, size, maturity and sector, and adjusted to a median of 4.15 per cent. The tribunal annulled: an authority cannot condemn a sample and then use its median, and in 2019 no rule required the median.

The facts

The taxpayer is a Portuguese company, 99.66 per cent owned by a non-resident group company; the authority applied the Portugal–Spain convention to the interest. The parent lent it €25 million, maturing on 31 January 2023, to fund ordinary operations, including refinancing, investment and acquisitions. The rate was 6.098 per cent a year, payable twice yearly on an actual/360 basis. In 2019 the taxpayer paid €1,545,673.61 of interest and withheld nothing, relying on the domestic exemption for interest paid to a qualifying EU parent.

The file applied the comparable uncontrolled price method. The taxpayer rated itself with Moody's RiskCalc at Ba3 on a one-year horizon and Ba2 on five, without setting out the assumptions behind either. A database search returned 352 debt issues; manual screening on sector, credit risk and other criteria removed 304. Against the remaining 48, the rate sat between the third quartile and the maximum.

The authority opened an inspection of 2019 in April 2022 and listed five weaknesses: possible outliers, inconsistent treatment of rating (only one of the 48 comparables carried one), disparity of amounts, latitude on maturity and inconsistent sectors. It cut the set to 15, later 14, and adjusted to the median of 4.15 per cent, with an interquartile range of 4.05 to 5.00 per cent. That added €493,763.89 to taxable profit, with corresponding relief under the net financing cost limitation. Because the withholding exemption covers only arm's length interest, it also assessed €123,440.97 of withholding tax on the excess, citing article 11(6) of the convention. The total due, with compensatory interest, was €140,387.90.

The litigation

Administrative claim | filed April 2023 | rejected August 2025

The authority took more than two years to reject the reclamação graciosa.

CAAD Tribunal Arbitral Coletivo | 27 August 2026 | taxpayer prevails

The tribunal first rejected the authority's objection that it could not order a refund: the amount was certain, and the authority had calculated it.

On the merits, it put the burden on the authority. Under article 74 of the general tax law the authority must prove not only the special relationship but that independent parties would have agreed different terms, and article 77(3) imposes an enhanced duty to give reasons. Criticising the taxpayer's study is not enough.

Each criticism failed that test. A Tukey outlier filter applied to the original 48 still left the rate inside the range, which ran from 2.15 to 7.00 per cent. Sector is not a specific comparability factor under the 2001 Portaria, and the search had already been confined to six sectors. On rating, amount and maturity the authority proposed no alternative method, so it had not shown that the taxpayer's was not the most appropriate. And because the comparable uncontrolled price method demands the highest degree of comparability, the authority could not take as its price the median of a sample it had itself found deficient in the most relevant criterion, the rating. Following CAAD 200/2022-T, paragraphs 3.57 and 3.62 of the Guidelines sit at the end of a process of removing weaker comparables. They are not a licence to apply the median to a sample condemned as a whole.

Decisive, the tribunal said, was the law in force. Only article 6(6) of Portaria 268/2021, effective from 1 January 2021, provides that a positive adjustment should as a rule be made to the median. For 2019 there was no legal basis for it, and a rate inside the range complied with the arm's length principle (following CAAD 71/2024-T). The taxpayer's alternative study, put forward in the arbitration, did not need to be considered.

Net result. The taxpayer prevails. The 2019 corporate income tax and withholding tax assessments, and the rejection of the administrative claim, are annulled. €140,387.90 is to be refunded with indemnity interest from the dates of payment. The authority bears the arbitration fee of €3,060.

ajiho commentary

The win belongs to the year, not the file

Take away the transitional point and the case is weaker than the result suggests. From 2021 the Portaria tells the authority to adjust to the median as a rule. The same file, for a 2021 year, would have met that rule with a rate above the third quartile, and above it even on the taxpayer's own outlier-filtered range, where the third quartile is 5.30 per cent. Groups relying on this decision for open years after 2020 are relying on the wrong part of it.

A loan CUP without ratings has not tested the loan

The authority's best point was the one it did least with. One rated comparable in 48, and a self-assessed rating with undocumented inputs, means the search never tested the factor that drives a loan price most. The tribunal let that pass because the authority offered nothing better. An authority that brings a rating-consistent sample of its own will not lose the same way. The taxpayer's fallback study shows what repair looks like after the event: seven comparables, adjusted for rating, size and maturity, and a 20.2 per cent liquidity discount drawn from a 1999 study of restricted stock, which the authority attacked as irrelevant to debt.

You cannot condemn a sample and price off its middle

This is the portable holding, and it now runs through a line of CAAD decisions. Paragraphs 3.57 and 3.62 come at the end of a sequence: exclude the weaker comparables, adjust where you can, and only then reach for a central measure to deal with defects that cannot be quantified. An authority that declares every comparable defective has not reached the last step. The logic binds taxpayers equally.

Excess interest carries a second tax

The withholding assessment deserves more attention than it will get. Treaty and domestic exemptions cover arm's length interest; the excess falls outside them and is taxed as domestic law provides. Here that was €123,440.97 on a €493,763.89 adjustment, a quarter of the excess, on top of the corporate tax. Any intra-group interest paid under an exemption carries this exposure whenever the rate is challenged.

Who carries the burden decided it

After CAAD 68/2025-T, where the authority's Banco de Portugal averages were rejected again, this is another Portuguese decision lost on how the authority priced, not on whether the taxpayer's price was right. Six days earlier, Uganda's Tax Appeals Tribunal doubted the authority's loan method in Mini Bakeries and upheld it anyway, because the burden there sat on the taxpayer. The same weakness produced opposite results.

What this means for your business

On Portuguese years before 2021. A median adjustment has no statutory basis, and a rate anywhere in a properly supported range complies. Where the authority attacks the sample without building its own, the CAAD line is consistent.

On years from 2021. Plan for the median. A rate in the upper quartile is defensible only with a rating-consistent sample behind it.

On the rating. Document the credit assessment (model, inputs, horizon) and screen comparables against it. It is the factor an authority will test first.

On exempt interest. Model the withholding cost of an adjustment, not only the corporate tax.

ajiho will continue to monitor Portuguese arbitral decisions on intra-group financing and cover further decisions in future FT Cases.

Case reference

A…, Lda v Autoridade Tributária e Aduaneira, CAAD (Centro de Arbitragem Administrativa), Tribunal Arbitral Coletivo, Processo n.º 979/2025-T, decided 27 August 2026. Arbitrators: Carlos Alberto Fernandes Cadilha (President), Miguel Matos Torres, João Taborda da Gama (Rapporteur). Tax year 2019. The decision is anonymised. Primary source: official CAAD decision. Decisions cited by the tribunal include CAAD 200/2022-T, 71/2024-T, 733/2015-T and 223/2020-T; Tribunal Central Administrativo Sul, 246/10.3BESNT (27 March 2025); Supremo Tribunal Administrativo, 766/11.2BEAVR (12 May 2021).

The decision dates notification of the rejection of the administrative claim to 14 August 2025 in its findings of fact, and to an official letter of 29.07.2026 in its introduction; the latter appears to be an error for 2025. The lender's country of residence is not stated; it is inferred from the treaty the authority applied.

This article is published by ajiho for general information only. It reflects ajiho’s own analysis of publicly available sources and does not constitute legal, tax or professional advice, nor a substitute for taking it. No client or confidential information is used in any Signal publication. Where the subject is a court or tribunal decision, the summary is ajiho’s reading of the published judgment and does not account for any subsequent appeal or development. You should take specific professional advice before acting on anything set out here.

Have an arrangement that raises the same question? That’s a conversation worth having.